Scarpa Mescalito approach shoe

RRP £185 – but check our deal-finder for a good price....

Scarpa Mescalito approach shoe: basics

The latest incarnation of the Scarpa Mescalito range of approach shoes and walking boots, this shoe is designed to cope with the toughest dry-weather walks and scrambles, yet provide all-day comfort. The shoe combines lightweight uppers, outsole and rand, and yet remains strong and stiff enough to conquer the rockiest of trails. A key comfort feature is the adjustable lacing, which extends almost to the toe, meaning you can tweak the fit to get it as snug as possible.

Straight from the box: the Scarpa Mescalito approach shoe in mint condition. Image: Scarpa

First impressions

The three colour schemes of this walking shoe are all subtle and classy but with rugged undertones. I tested the Thyme Green-Forest colour scheme and was quite happy to wear them into a pub or café after the walk. New to Scarpa, a lightweight PU rand – the strip that runs around the base of the uppers – is tough enough to protect vulnerable parts of the foot and the rubber toe cap offers extra protection. Like the Mescalito TRK GTX boots, the approach shoe has an unusual lace-to-toe design. Some walkers will find the logo on the heel a bit shouty.

Suede walking shoes. — Fergus's sample Mescalito shoes look battle-hardened after weeks of wear on the Brecon Beacons. Image: BBC Countyfile Magazine / Fergus Collins

Are they waterproof?

Only to a point. The suede uppers will resist a scattering of raindrops, but on a prolonged walk in wet grass and crops these low-cut shoes became waterlogged. Water gets in through the toe-end lace holes.

Suede approach shoes — The hard-wearing Vibram Dynamic outsole delivered impressive grip. Image: BBC Countryfile Magazine / Fergus Collins

Do they grip well?

The Vibram rubber soles are stiff and but the lugs are large compared to other walking shoes that I have worn and I found them surprisingly grippy when descending long, muddy slopes. They also gripped wet rocks without any slippage.

Scarpa_Mescalito_crop3 — The mescalito is an approach shoe rather than a climbing shoe, but like traditional climbing shoes, the lacing system extends almost to the end of the toes, and makes a close fit much easier to achieve. *Image: Scarpa*

Will they fit me?

With a stretch-fit tongue and lace-to-toe design, you can adjust the fit to get the snug hold – and these regular fit shoes clung to my rather narrow feet. Allied to this, the embossed suede upper will adjust to your foot shape.

How do they feel?

The Mescalito is designed to tackle scrambles and long walks in challenging terrain, so in traditional approach-shoe style, the sole is quite stiff and the overall body of the shoe is solid rather than supple. That said, the incredibly comfortable EVA midsole provides superb cushioning – better than most traditional approach shoes – and the suede upper create a snug fit. Over the many walks I’ve taken in the Brecon Beacons, my feet were perfectly happy. It took me a few short walks and many micro-adjustments to get a tight hold on my foot to reduce slip and movement. They were also very easy to get on and off.

The lack of a waterproof membrane has pros as well as the cons mentioned above. While designed to be breathable, waterproof membranes can nevertheless trap warm, moist air inside the shoe, making your feet feel hot and sweaty in warm weather. So when the sun comes out, a shoe like the Scarpa Mescalito will feel cooler.

Use for…

Dry weather hiking in rugged terrain. The excellent comfort, snug fit and solid grip offer confidence and security over long distances. Not recommended for walks in long wet grass, boggy areas or during prolonged rain.

			
Facts at a glance: Scarpa Mescalito approach shoe

Uppers: Thermo-embossed Suede
Outsole: Vibram Dynamis
Midsole: Bi density EVA
Waterproofing: Suede
Fitting: Regular
Weight: 780g per pair

Also consider...

Cotswold Wychwood Low walking shoe

RRP £69.99

Brown walking shoe — If you enjoy short strolls rather than epic treks, Cotswold's Wychwood shoe may suit you fine. *Image: BBC Countryfile Magazine / Steve Sayers*

If you are on a tight budget, consider this relatively affordable option from Gloucestershire shoe-maker Cotswold. The waterproof membrane works pretty well, the outsoles grip in most conditions, and they feel comfortable, with decent cushioning in the midsole. Watch out though – sizes run small, and you might want to check your heel feels secure as you move, too. But if they do fit, then these could be a money-saving option for occasional walkers who enjoy short strolls on easy trails rather than long hikes on tough, rocky trails.

Ready to buy? then check out our deal-finder...

Columbia Peakfreak II Mid Outdry

RRP £125

Muddy hiking shoes — Stable, grippy and waterproof: the Peakfreak II Mid Outdry. *Image: BBC Countryfile Magazine / Joe Pontin*

Technically a boot (Columbia classifies the ankle collar as of 'mid' height), the Peakfreak II Mid Outdry is arguably closer to a shoe. Sure, there is a little ankle support, but the overall vibe is light, lowish and generally shoe-y. Super comfortable, they have an excellent and exceptional broad lacing system for a close fit. They feel stable and grippy and the Outdry membrane is highly waterproof. Hunt around and may find it for less than £100 – a good price for a shoe you can trust to protect your feet over long distances in spring, summer and autumn, though you might prefer something beefier in winter. For more info, check out our more detailed review of the Peakfreak II Mid Outdry.

Ready to buy? then check out our deal-finder...

Still looking for the right shoe? Then check out our round-up of the best walking shoes for 2023.

Scarpa Mescalito approach shoe